High school project idea · Law, Policy & Society

Build a Youth Policy Scorecard

Create a transparent way to judge whether a policy proposal works for young people, not just whether it sounds good.

Develop and apply a balanced scorecard to several policies affecting youth while making values, evidence, and uncertainty visible.

Original Compass project by Davisville LabsReviewed August 2026Goal real work, evidence, and reflectionEditorial standards →

Why this project matters

Learn by doing something real.

Develop and apply a balanced scorecard to several policies affecting youth while making values, evidence, and uncertainty visible. This project feels different from a school assignment because the student serves young people, families, advocates, and decision makers comparing proposals, creates something visible, tests it honestly, responds to feedback, and explains the decisions behind the final result.

What you will create

Your project plan

Use these deliverables as milestones for Build a Youth Policy Scorecard. Adapt the details to your interests, available time, and real-world opportunities.

  1. 01

    Case record and stakeholder evidence

    Research youth-defined outcomes, effectiveness, equity, rights, cost, feasibility, implementation, evidence quality, unintended effects, and weighting. Document the needs, constraints, credible sources, and perspectives of young people, families, advocates, and decision makers comparing proposals.

  2. 02

    Legal or policy analysis framework

    Turn the evidence into a focused plan for the youth policy scorecard and comparative report, including success criteria, ethical boundaries, scope, and a realistic path to completion.

  3. 03

    Draft hearing, guide, or proposal

    Create the first complete version of the youth policy scorecard and comparative report. Include a youth needs brief, scoring criteria, weighting rationale, source protocol, scored policy set, sensitivity analysis, and recommendations.

  4. 04

    Deliberation and revision record

    facilitate a scoring session with youth and adult reviewers, compare disagreements, and test how different weights change rankings Record what happened, what failed, what users or reviewers said, and which changes you made.

  5. 05

    Final civic case study

    Publish the final youth policy scorecard and comparative report with a portfolio-ready case study showing the challenge, evidence, process, revisions, results, limits, and next version.

Make the work stronger

What separates a finished project from a meaningful one?

For Build a Youth Policy Scorecard, use these checkpoints to protect the quality of the work without turning the project into a performance for admissions.

Avoid this

  • Starting the youth policy scorecard and comparative report before understanding young people, families, advocates, and decision makers comparing proposals
  • Treating assumptions or internet opinions as real evidence
  • Choosing a scope too large to test and finish with care

Evidence that it is working

  • The audience and real problem are clearly defined
  • Research and evidence are documented
  • A working youth policy scorecard and comparative report was created

If you want to go further

  • Test the work with at least five additional people from young people, families, advocates, and decision makers comparing proposals
  • Interview a professional connected to Policy Evaluation and compare their advice with your approach

Skills you can build

Capabilities that travel beyond this project.

Evaluation FrameworksPolicy ResearchYouth VoicePolicy AnalysisCivic Communication

College application value

Use the project as evidence, not decoration.

Can demonstrate initiative, curiosity, reflection, and growth through the student’s choices, response to setbacks, work with young people, families, advocates, and decision makers comparing proposals, and development of Evaluation Frameworks, Policy Research, and Youth Voice.

Civic EngagementCritical ThinkingCommunicationLeadershipResearch

The goal of Build a Youth Policy Scorecard is not to manufacture an impressive activity. Do real work, keep evidence of the process, and reflect honestly on what changed.

How this guide was made

Build a Youth Policy Scorecard is an original Compass educational starting point designed around real work, visible evidence, feedback, and reflection. It is not an admissions guarantee.

Read editorial standards →
Ready to build it?

Turn this idea into a step-by-step Compass project.

Try this project in Compass